I'm right chuffed with the new guide. It seems like a lifetime ago that a pint in the Gallt y Glyn brought me into the Ground up fold. Not only is it a thing of beauty, it gives me an opertunity to be extremly nerdy. Yes I'm a geek and like nothing more than some qualitative analysis of random trivia; in this case the Star ratings on the new guide.
Star ratings are initially arbitrarity applied be the authors (Pete, Simon and I) in relation to some control specimen (in this case the Dervish ***). this subjective round of applause is then glanced at by a crack cadre of nitpickers (the proof reading/ soundboarding team) who may dissagree / notice them.
So how to present my findings? Tables! (wrong data for graphs)
Ok lists, I'm not blog literate enough.
Basically I was wanting to see who saw and delivered the good routes, whose quests were of quality rather than cack.
Up first the Top ten of Slateheads with routes of three stars (or more)
Rank ][ Slate Head ][ No. of *** Routes
1 J Dawes
10
2 D Towse / J Redhead
8
3 P Williams
7
4 G Smith
5
4 N Harms
5
6 S Haston
4
7 C Phillips
3
7 M Crook
3
7 P Pritchard
3
7 J Sylvester
3As you can see I've put Towse and Redhead together, as in the quarries they were joined at the hip anyway....
The next list is a biggy; The top 20 starred slate heads based on total stars awarded.
After the quantity of stars I've added in brackets this figure divided by the total no. of routes in the quarries that they've sired - a sort of average star rating....
Rank ][ Slatehead ][ Total no. of Stars (average star rating)1 J Dawes
42 (2)
2 I Lloyd Jones
41 (0.64)
3 N Harms
39 (1.63)
4 D Towse / J Redhead
36 (2.77)
5 S Haston
35 (1.17)
5 P Pritchard
35 (1.59)
7 P Williams
28 (2)
8 M Crook
26 (1.3)
9 G Smith
25 (1.47)
10 M Raine
22 (1.38)
11 C Dale
20 (1.18)
12 C Phillips
18 (0.43)
13 C Parkin
16 (1.07)
14 C Davies
14 (0.82)
14 J Ratcliffe
14 (1.75)
16 B Wayman
13 (1.08)
16 P Hawkins
13 (1.08)
18 R Drury
12 (1.2)
18 J Sylvester
12 (2)
18 M Dicken
12 (0.5)
Rankings in italics are tied. Please note that all data collection and proccessing was fueled either by insomnia or coffee, so may contain
some errors.
Make of it what you will....